Nordic identity in Estonia

Jump to navigation Jump to search

A proposed cross flag design
An Estonian cross flag on the island of Vormsi
Estonian cross flag proposal from 1919

Nordic identity in Estonia refers to opinions that Estonia is one of the Nordic countries (Põhjamaad in Estonian) or that it should/will be considered as such in the future. The current mainstream view outside of Estonia does not usually include it among them, but categorizing Estonia as a Nordic country is very common in Estonia.[1]

A push towards being defined as a Nordic country has existed in independent Estonia since the war of independence in 1918, however, gaining official membership of the Nordic region alongside with neighbuoring Finland was interrupted by the occupation of the Soviet Union after World War II.[clarification needed] [2][3] Estonia has been interested in joining the Nordic region again since 1991, when it regained its independence from the Soviet Union's occupation and annexation. The Estonian language is closely related to the Finnish language, both are Finnic languages. The Swedish indigenous minority called eestirootslased or rannarootslased in Estonian, and estlandssvenskar or aibofolket in Swedish has lived officially in Estonia since the 13th century similarly to Finnish Swedes in Finland. The extensive settlement of Swedes in Northern and Western Estonia, especially in the islands and coastal areas, has had a significant impact on Estonian culture and also language. Historically, Swedes have made up about 25% of the population of Tallinn, the capital, and even more in Haapsalu. The number of Swedes in Estonia, including in these cities, fell sharply due to the Soviet occupation.[4] The Scandinavian connection from the Estonian Viking Age and later from being a part of the Danish and Swedish Empires for few centuries, especially Northern Estonia (historically called Estland), left a lasting influence on the creation of the Estonian identity during the national awakening period of the 19th century.[5]

One of the most important trade partners of Estonia are the Nordic countries. Estonia's largest import and export partners from the Nordic countries are Finland and Sweden (23% of all export and 20% of all import in July 2020). Three quarters of the investments that go to Estonia come from the Nordic countries, especially from Finland.[6]

Public attitudes[edit]

53.3% of ethnically Estonian youth consider belonging in the Nordic identity group as important or very important for them. 52.2% have the same attitude towards the "Baltic" identity group, according to a research study from 2013.[7]

The image that Estonian youths have of their identity is rather similar to that of the Finns as far as the identities of being a citizen of one’s own country, a Fenno-Ugric person, or a Nordic person are concerned, while our identity as a citizen of Europe is common ground between us and Latvians - being stronger here than it is among the young people of Finland and Sweden.[7]

...the importance of being a Nordic country has risen to an equal level with the Baltic identity among young people[7]

Sociologist Mikko Lagerspetz has observed that the attitudes towards the Nordic identity in the Estonian society can be grouped in three: 1) Estonia is already a Nordic country; 2) Estonia needs to become a Nordic country but is not there yet; 3) Estonia should walk its own unique path.[8]

In 2020, the University of Tartu conducted a psychological survey with 6th grade students to find out, among other things, which countries they consider to be the most important and closest to Estonia. The study was performed by drawing. Ethnic Estonian students depicted Estonia the most, together with Sweden, Finland and other Nordic countries, leaving Latvia, Lithuania and Russia generally undrawn. Non-Estonian students (mostly Russians) on the contrary portrayed Estonia with the Baltic states and also with Russia. This shows that ethnic Estonian (6th graders) consider themselves as one of the Nordic nations and we can assume that this view is common in younger ethnic Estonians including young adults.[9]

Modern political narrative[edit]

An important element in Estonia's post-independence reorientation has been closer ties with the Nordic countries, especially Finland and Sweden. In December 1999, then Estonian foreign minister (and President of Estonia from 2006 until 2016) Toomas Hendrik Ilves delivered a speech titled "Estonia as a Nordic Country" to the Swedish Institute for International Affairs.[10] In 2003, the foreign ministry also hosted an exhibit called "Estonia: Nordic with a Twist".[11]

In 2015, the Estonian prime minister Taavi Rõivas defined the country's narrative as a "New Nordic Country", or "Uus Põhjamaa".[12]

A conference comprising the heads of the coalition government was held in September 2016, discussing Estonia's outlook as a Nordic country.[13]

Becoming a new Nordic country does not necessarily mean that we will emulate the Nordic countries – copying will never make us anything else than a poor copy of Sweden. We have got to get to where we need to with more courage to take risks, we need to show more initiative, to experiment more and to also make more mistakes, not just limit ourselves to learning from others and continuing to compare ourselves against others. - Taavi Rõivas, Prime Minister of Estonia[14]

Kersti Kaljulaid, president of Estonia since 2016, commented on views of then Estonian foreign minister Ilves, saying that she does not want to use "loaded words" like Nordic or Baltic but prefers to call like-minded countries of northern Europe the "Nordic Benelux".[15]

The Nordic narrative is also communicated by government agencies:

  • Invest in Estonia – The national investment agency[16]
  • Brand Estonia [17]
  • RMK – The national forestry organization[18]
  • Enterprise Estonia[19]
  • The Foreign Ministry[11][20]

When state-owned Estonian flag carrier was renamed as Nordica in 2016, Erik Sakkov, then board member of the company, explained the airline's naming (according to some Estonian media outlets) with Estonia's continual self-identification among Nordic countries (Põhjamaad in Estonian) and with country's leaders wish to emphasize it in the name of the national carrier.[21][22] However, similar explanation by Sakkov which was published on Nordica homepage in English, claimed that motivation behind naming was Estonia's alignment with "Northern Europe" and country's leaders wish to reflect that.[23]

The Swedish ambassador to Estonia, Mr. Anders Ljunggren, has claimed in 2015 that Estonia would have been considered a Nordic country by the other Nordic countries, "had the history been different...The differences between Estonia and Sweden have become less year by year, owing to the fact that the two countries have gotten to know each other more each year".[24]

Criticism[edit]

The Tuglas foundation has claimed that the Nordic definition that Estonia is moving towards does not exist anymore, being a relic of past times.[25]

Per Högselius wrote an opinion piece about the topic in 2003, looking at the idea as fringe, but concluding that "in time the Estonians might be able to persuade us".[26]

Ethnic Estonians who were active during the process of regaining Estonia's independence are more likely to consider Estonia as a Baltic country instead of a Nordic country because of the events that were undertaken together with two neighboring Baltic nations, that were also annexed by Soviet Union, to gain greater world attention, for example the Baltic Way. They usually represent the age group of 45 and older. It also has to do with Soviet propaganda that tried to replace the Finnish and Estonian relationship and bond with a "Baltic unity" bond as a Soviet geopolitical vision. This vision is still widespread outside of Estonia.[27]

Historic contacts with the Nordic Council[edit]

The Nordic Council had historically been a strong supporter of Estonian independence from the Soviet Union. The Nordic Council of Ministers' Office in Estonia was opened in spring 1991.[28]

See also[edit]

References[edit]

  1. ^ Kuldkepp, Mart. "Eesti põhjamaise identiteedi ajaloost" – via www.academia.edu. Cite journal requires |journal= (help)
  2. ^ "Tiia Kõnnussaar: Eesti kui põhjamaa – elujõuline unistus | Eetikaveeb". Eetika.ee (in Estonian). 22 August 2016. Retrieved 16 December 2016.
  3. ^ Estonia Gravitates Towards Sweden: Nordic Identity and Activist Regionalism in World War I | Mart Kuldkepp. Academia.edu. 1 January 1970. Retrieved 16 December 2016.
  4. ^ "Tallinn's Swedish St Michael's Church - Estonian Swedes".
  5. ^ Kuldkepp, Mart (2013). "The Scandinavian Connection in Early Estonian Nationalism". Journal of Baltic Studies. 44 (3): 313–338. doi:10.1080/01629778.2012.744911.
  6. ^ "Statistics Estonia".
  7. ^ a b c "Identity in an Open World". Archived from the original on 23 August 2018. Retrieved 20 September 2017.
  8. ^ "Põhjamaade saadikud soovivad Eestile rohkem diskussiooni valupunktide üle". 26 June 2017.
  9. ^ "Delfi: "The children of Narva and Tartu were asked to draw what Estonia and Russia would look like as people"".
  10. ^ Ilves, Toomas Hendrik (14 December 1999). "Estonia as a Nordic Country". Estonian Foreign Ministry. Retrieved 10 October 2020.
  11. ^ a b "Estonia – Nordic with a Twist". Archived from the original on 8 February 2008.
  12. ^ "Taavi Rõivas: Eesti suur narratiiv on Uus Põhjamaa | Reformierakond". Reform.ee. 10 January 2015. Retrieved 16 December 2016.
  13. ^ ""Estonia AND the Nordic countries – Estonia AS a Nordic country?" conference summary and videos". Norden.ee. Retrieved 16 December 2016.
  14. ^ "Prime Minister Rõivas in his address to the nation on Independence Day: Estonia has many reasons to be a confident country".
  15. ^ "Kersti Kaljulaid: Let's talk about the Nordic Benelux". Public Broadcasting of Latvia. 25 October 2016. Retrieved 16 December 2016.
  16. ^ "Estonia - Nordic With A Twist". Invest in Estonia. 15 September 2015. Retrieved 16 December 2016.
  17. ^ "Character — Brand Estonia".
  18. ^ "RMK has the most visited forestry-related homepage | RMK". Rmk.ee. Retrieved 16 December 2016.
  19. ^ "EAS - Ettevõtluse Arendamise Sihtasutus". Eas.ee. Retrieved 16 December 2016.
  20. ^ "Estonia as a Nordic Country | Välisministeerium". Vm.ee (in Estonian). 14 December 1999. Retrieved 16 December 2016.
  21. ^ Nordic Aviation Groupi uueks nimeks saab Nordica. Eesti Ekspress, 8 March 2016
  22. ^ Eesti lennufirma saab uue nime, Äripäev, 8 March 2016
  23. ^ Nordica - the story behind the new name of the airline
  24. ^ "Mis on Põhjamaade edu saladus?". 12 June 2015.
  25. ^ "Tuglas-seura | Kas Eesti on Põhjamaa?". Tuglas.fi. Retrieved 16 December 2016.
  26. ^ "Estland längtar så in i Norden | Per Högselius | SvD". Svd.se. 20 November 2003. Retrieved 16 December 2016.
  27. ^ "Sofi Oksanen: "Your silence doesn't protect you"".
  28. ^ "Intro". norden.ee.